Talk About Network



Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Programming > Functional > Re: a golden ol...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 25 of 40 Topic 2778 of 2841
Post > Topic >>

Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza

by William James <w_a_x_man@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Feb 24, 2008 at 06:42 AM

Stevan Apter wrote:
> yes it does.

What does what?  Please don't top-post.

>
> prompts:
>
> e"hi. i'm going to be your worst nightmare"
> e"i think you're full of it."
> e"my mother told me so."
> e"no. you tell me about yours."
> e"you're obviously retarded."
> e"damn your eyes!"
> e"understand a kick in the pants?"
> e"i always ignore idiots."
> e"i am afraid of dinosaurs"
>
> responses:
>
> "have you always been going to be my worst nightmare?
> "why do you think i am full of it?"
> "tell me about your mother."
> "please don't be so personal."
> "can you elaborate on that?"
> "can you elaborate on that?"
> "that's very interesting.  do go on."
> "why do you always ignore idiots?"
> "have you always been afraid of dinosaurs?"

The K (not the Q) program was:

e:{$[(#b)=i:(|/'b:(w@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(w:(`$" "\:x@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 in".?"))in`)in\:/:A)?1b;E@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
     " "~n:c@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(c:{x@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 i)ss/:N;c
     .q.ssr[c;n;" "/:$(),P'(w[k],p:1_'(0,1+k:b[i]?1b)_`,w)"I"$n]]}

I don't see "you", "your", "my", "myself", "yourself", etc.
So how can it change "your" to "my"?
I was talking about the K program; you're talking about the Q program.

>
> a few observations:
>
> the 'i' function gives you prompt-and-respond in the console by
> call 'e' until the user gives no prompt:
>
> i:{while[count r:read0 0;-1"? ",e r;]}

I was talking about the K program; you're talking about the Q program.

>
> the 'P' function maps first- and second-person:
>
> P:{(y,x,z)(x,y)?z}.`$(("you";"your";"yourself";"i'm";"i
am");("i";"my";"myself";"you are";"you're"))

So this will change "your" to "my".  Will it, like the Ruby program,
change "my" to "your"?

>
> instead of rotating multiple-responses, the k version picks a
> response randomly from the set.  this is less predictable than
> rotation.

That has the defect of possibly repeating the same response
immediately instead of cycling through all of the responses
before repeating.

>
> but i'm not surprised that the ruby version is so small.  it's
> a nice language, and i like the enthusiasm of its practitioners.
>
> "William James" <w_a_x_man@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message
news:a404c407-ac00-4665-9f49-6bca822c1239@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> > On Feb 24, 6:06 am, Mark Tarver <dr.mtar...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
> >> Sorry I missed a couple of later attempts
> >>
> >> Lisp                       150 LOC  ................ Peter Norvig
> >> Qi (slightly revised)  63 LOC   .................Mark Tarver
> >> Ruby                      53 LOC   .................William James
> >> Q                           10 LOC   ..................Steven Apter
> >> K                             3 LOC  ...................Steven Apter
> >> Ruby (again)            17 LOC ...................William James
> >> Mathematica            20 LOC .................. Szabolcs
> >>
> >> Mark
> >
> > The K version doesn't do everything that the Ruby
> > versions do.  It doesn't change "I" in the user's
> > response to "you" when throwing it back at the user,
> > for example.
> >
> > When there are multiple possible replies to a user's
> > input, the Ruby program rotates those replies so that
> > not one will be repeated until all have been used.




 40 Posts in Topic:
a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Mark Tarver <dr.mtarve  2008-02-22 03:49:44 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Mark Tarver <dr.mtarve  2008-02-22 03:59:02 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
William James <w_a_x_m  2008-02-22 14:09:58 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
"John Thingstad"  2008-02-23 13:00:30 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
"Stevan Apter"   2008-02-23 13:21:00 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Ken Tilton <kennytilto  2008-02-23 15:24:42 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
"Stevan Apter"   2008-02-23 16:42:31 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Ken Tilton <kennytilto  2008-02-23 20:55:56 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
"Stevan Apter"   2008-02-24 07:44:32 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Mark Tarver <dr.mtarve  2008-02-22 17:12:49 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
William James <w_a_x_m  2008-02-22 19:19:31 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Szabolcs <szhorvat@[EM  2008-02-23 14:12:17 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Szabolcs <szhorvat@[EM  2008-02-23 14:26:03 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Ben Bacarisse <ben.use  2008-02-24 00:01:08 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
William James <w_a_x_m  2008-02-23 20:14:36 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Szabolcs <szhorvat@[EM  2008-02-24 01:51:00 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Mark Tarver <dr.mtarve  2008-02-24 03:59:56 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Rainer Joswig <joswig@  2008-02-24 18:29:12 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Neelakantan Krishnaswami   2008-02-24 18:03:20 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Mark Tarver <dr.mtarve  2008-02-24 04:06:09 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
William James <w_a_x_m  2008-02-24 05:30:38 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
"Stevan Apter"   2008-02-24 08:59:51 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
William James <w_a_x_m  2008-02-24 06:22:31 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
"Stevan Apter"   2008-02-24 09:37:17 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
William James <w_a_x_m  2008-02-24 06:42:47 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
"Stevan Apter"   2008-02-24 10:56:28 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
William James <w_a_x_m  2008-02-24 06:57:22 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Dimitre Liotev <notmy@  2008-02-24 10:00:29 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
"Stevan Apter"   2008-02-24 10:49:22 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Arved Sandstrom <asand  2008-02-24 17:28:25 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
"Stevan Apter"   2008-02-24 13:03:11 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Ken Tilton <kennytilto  2008-02-24 13:59:55 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Dimitre Liotev <notmy@  2008-02-24 11:18:27 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
William James <w_a_x_m  2008-02-24 12:36:12 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
William James <w_a_x_m  2008-02-24 13:11:47 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
William James <w_a_x_m  2008-02-24 13:26:38 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Arved Sandstrom <asand  2008-02-25 17:16:43 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
William James <w_a_x_m  2008-02-24 13:35:20 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
Brian Adkins <lojicdot  2008-02-25 09:52:13 
Re: a golden oldie challenge: Eliza
"Stevan Apter"   2008-02-25 16:58:13 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Fri May 16 4:56:29 CDT 2008.