Talk About Network



Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Programming > Cobol > Re: Interesting...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 65 of 74 Topic 4071 of 4167
Post > Topic >>

Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)

by "William M. Klein" <wmklein@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Apr 14, 2008 at 02:24 PM

<previous info deleted>

some of this thread reminds me of one of my (many) lost battlers during
the 
development of the '02 COBOL standard.

I never liked the implications of the syntax

  Invoke object-reference "method-name" using passed-parameters

It always seemed to me that what was really happening was that a "message"
was 
being sent to the object-reference to be processed BY "method-name" using 
passed-parameters. or in pseudo-syntax

Send Message to object-reference for "method-name" using passed-parameters

I can't think of any other case in which two "operands" follow a COBOL
statement 
name before a preposition where the two have "different" uses, e.g.

 Compute filed-1 field-2 = arithmetic expression

In this case, "field-1" and field-2 are simply repeated receiving
operands.

I didn't even think that object-reference is the "object of the verb"
INVOKE 
(English grammar, not "object" in OO sense)

Are you really "invoking" an object reference? or are you sending
something to 
it?

Oh well, it is certainly too late now, but I this thread did remind me of
the 
old issue.

-- 
Bill Klein
 wmklein <at> ix.netcom.com




 74 Posts in Topic:
Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-28 12:08:44 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Howard Brazee <howard@  2008-03-28 11:22:51 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-28 13:10:05 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Howard Brazee <howard@  2008-03-28 12:31:28 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-28 14:33:27 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-28 14:53:00 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-03-29 10:16:59 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-28 18:01:42 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Charles Hottel"  2008-03-28 22:57:57 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Alistair <alistair@[EM  2008-03-29 12:01:10 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-03-30 09:05:25 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
docdwarf@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-03-30 01:03:06 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Robert <no@[EMAIL PROT  2008-03-29 23:19:59 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Alistair <alistair@[EM  2008-04-01 11:23:23 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"tlmfru" <la  2008-03-28 14:07:59 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Howard Brazee <howard@  2008-03-28 13:54:59 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Kellie Fitton <KELLIEF  2008-03-28 14:11:19 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-28 18:54:27 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Charles Hottel"  2008-03-28 22:50:47 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-28 22:47:17 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Kellie Fitton <KELLIEF  2008-03-28 14:13:40 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Charles Hottel"  2008-03-28 22:55:47 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Alistair <alistair@[EM  2008-03-28 18:10:10 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Alistair <alistair@[EM  2008-03-28 18:12:53 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
docdwarf@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-03-29 01:15:20 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-03-30 08:59:23 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Richard <riplin@[EMAIL  2008-03-28 13:41:46 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-03-29 10:42:50 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-28 19:20:59 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Charles Hottel"  2008-03-28 23:01:10 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"tlmfru" <la  2008-03-31 12:20:41 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-01 12:44:13 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
docdwarf@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-04-01 00:01:46 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-02 10:50:55 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Richard <riplin@[EMAIL  2008-04-01 16:24:52 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-02 13:40:05 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-28 19:51:12 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Richard <riplin@[EMAIL  2008-03-29 00:11:50 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-29 09:24:32 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-03-29 10:09:10 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-28 20:12:49 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-03-30 09:22:58 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-03-29 18:21:54 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-01 12:57:36 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Charles Hottel"  2008-03-28 22:47:37 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
tim <TimJ@[EMAIL PROTE  2008-03-29 06:18:19 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
tim <TimJ@[EMAIL PROTE  2008-03-29 06:27:30 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
tim <TimJ@[EMAIL PROTE  2008-03-29 20:47:39 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Joe Zitzelberger <zber  2008-04-11 00:15:30 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-11 16:39:41 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Richard Brady <rrllbrr  2008-04-11 13:51:06 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"tlmfru" <la  2008-04-11 12:54:50 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-12 12:50:19 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"tlmfru" <la  2008-04-12 19:20:03 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-13 21:07:14 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-12 12:36:35 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-04-11 14:29:11 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-12 18:55:25 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-04-12 13:47:33 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-04-12 14:42:48 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-13 20:33:47 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-04-13 22:39:57 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-14 15:34:49 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-04-13 23:47:34 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"William M. Klein&qu  2008-04-14 14:24:00 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Pete Dashwood"  2008-04-15 13:14:01 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Joe Zitzelberger <zber  2008-04-17 00:45:33 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Joe Zitzelberger <zber  2008-04-17 00:37:38 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Charles Hottel"  2008-04-12 12:14:32 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-04-12 15:11:35 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-04-14 13:40:11 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Rick Smith" &l  2008-04-11 13:03:05 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
Richard Brady <rrllbrr  2008-04-13 19:04:10 
Re: Interesting take on Paradigms (OO vs Procedural)
"Frank Swarbrick&quo  2008-04-14 18:10:40 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Fri Jul 4 21:33:31 CDT 2008.